In My Hands Today…

Posted on by
Reply

Histories of Nations: How Their Identities Were Forged – edited by Peter Furtado

Global histories tend to be written from the narrow viewpoint of a single author and a single perspective, with the inevitable bias that it entails. But in this thought-provoking collection, twenty-eight writers and scholars give engaging, often passionate accounts of their own nation’s history.

The countries have been selected to represent every continent and every type of state: large and small; mature democracies and religious autocracies; states that have existed for thousands of years; and those born as recently as the twentieth century. Together, they contain two-thirds of the world’s population.

In the United States, for example, the myth of the nation’s “historylessness” remains strong, but in China, history is seen to play a crucial role in legitimising three thousand years of imperial authority.

“History wars” over the content of textbooks rage in countries as diverse as Australia, Russia, and Japan. Some countries, such as Iran or Egypt, are blessed—or cursed—with a glorious ancient history that the present cannot equal; others, such as Germany, must find ways of approaching and reconciling the pain of the recent past.

Festivals of India: Madhvacharya Jayanti

Posted on by
Reply
Source

Commemorating the birth anniversary of Sri Madhvacharya, one of India’s most influential philosophers and theologians, Madhvacharya Jayanti typically falls in September or October according to the Gregorian calendar, marks the birth of a man who profoundly impacted Hindu philosophy and continues to inspire millions of followers worldwide.

Sri Madhvacharya, also known simply as Madhva, was born in 1238 in Pajaka, a small village near Udupi in the present-day state of Karnataka. He is renowned as the founder of the Dvaita or dualism school of Vedanta philosophy, which he called Tattvavada, meaning “arguments from a realist viewpoint”. 

Madhvacharya’s life was marked by extraordinary events from the very beginning. According to hagiographies, his birth was accompanied by divine signs and miracles. His parents, Madhyageha Bhatta and Vedavati had long yearned for a child and considered his birth a blessing from Lord Vishnu. Even as a young boy, Madhvacharya displayed remarkable intelligence and spiritual inclination. At the tender age of five, he received spiritual initiation, and by twelve, he had already accepted sannyasa, the most renounced order of spiritual life. This early renunciation set the stage for his lifelong dedication to spiritual pursuits and philosophical inquiry.

Madhvacharya’s contributions to Indian philosophy and theology are vast and enduring. His accomplishments can be broadly categorized into philosophical, literary, and social reforms.

Source

Madhvacharya’s most significant contribution was the formulation and propagation of the Dvaita or dualism school of Vedanta. This philosophy stands in contrast to the Advaita or non-dualism philosophy of Adi Shankara and the Vishishtadvaita or qualified non-dualism of Ramanuja. The Dvaita philosophy asserts that there are fundamental differences between the individual soul or jiva, matter or prakriti, and God or Ishvara.

Madhvacharya propounded the concept of five-fold differences or pancha bheda. The pancha bheda is was the difference between God and the individual soul; the difference between God and matter; the difference between individual souls; the difference between soul and matter; and the difference between various forms of matter.

Madhvacharya identified Vishnu as the Supreme Being, equating Him with Brahman as described in the Upanishads. Unlike some other Indian philosophical schools that viewed the world as an illusion, Madhvacharya asserted that the world is real and not merely an illusion or maya. Controversially, Madhvacharya proposed that some souls are eternally destined for hell, a concept not commonly found in Hindu philosophy.

Madhvacharya was a prolific writer, authoring numerous works that expounded his philosophy and interpreted sacred texts. His literary output is impressive, with thirty-seven works attributed to him. Some of his most important works include commentaries on the thirteen principal Upanishads, offering his unique interpretations of these ancient texts. His commentary on the Brahma Sutras, the foundational text of Vedanta philosophy, is considered one of his most important works. Madhvacharya’s commentary on the Bhagavad Gita provides insights into his understanding of karma yoga and bhakti yoga and the Mahabharata Tatparya Nirnaya presents his interpretation of the Mahabharata, emphasising its spiritual and philosophical aspects. The Bhagavata Tatparya Nirnaya is a commentary on the Bhagavata Purana, this work elucidates Madhvacharya’s views on devotion to Vishnu while the Anu-Vyakhyana, considered his masterpiece, is a supplement to his commentary on the Brahma Sutras.

Madhvacharya was not just a philosopher but also a social reformer. He challenged prevailing social norms and worked towards making spiritual knowledge accessible to all. Madhvacharya declared that the path to salvation was open to all, regardless of caste or birth. This was a revolutionary idea in medieval India, where spiritual knowledge was often restricted to upper castes. He established the Ashta Mathas or Eight Monasteries in Udupi, which became centres of learning and spiritual practice. Madhvacharya emphasized bhakti or devotion as a means of spiritual realisation, making spirituality more accessible to the common people.

The life of Madhvacharya is replete with stories of miraculous events and divine interventions. While these stories may be viewed as hagiographical embellishments, they form an integral part of the tradition and reflect the reverence in which Madhvacharya is held by his followers.

According to tradition, Madhvacharya’s birth was not ordinary. It is said that his parents had been childless for many years and prayed fervently to Lord Ananteshwara, a form of Lord Vishnu for a son. Their prayers were answered, and Madhvacharya was born as an incarnation of Vayu, the wind god.

Source

Several miraculous events are associated with Madhvacharya’s childhood. It is said that Madhvacharya’s father had accumulated many debts. To help repay these, young Madhva miraculously converted tamarind seeds into gold coins. Near Madhvacharya’s house lived a demon named Maniman in the form of a snake. The young Madhva is said to have killed this demon with the big toe of his left foot. Stories tell of Madhvacharya’s ability to appear instantly before his mother whenever she felt anxious, jumping from wherever he was playing. As a child, Madhvacharya is said to have consumed 4,000 bananas and thirty large pots of milk in one sitting, demonstrating his divine nature.

Madhvacharya is believed by his followers to be the third incarnation of Vayu, the wind god. According to this belief, the first incarnation was Lord Hanuman, the devoted servant of Lord Rama, the second was Bhima, one of the Pandava brothers in the Mahabharata while Madhvacharya was the third and final incarnation. This belief in Madhvacharya’s divine origin adds to his authority as a spiritual leader and philosopher in the eyes of his followers.

One of the most significant mythological stories associated with Madhvacharya is his supposed encounter with Vyasa, the legendary author of the Vedas and Puranas. According to tradition, Madhvacharya travelled to Badrikashrama in the Himalayas, where he met Vyasa in person. This meeting is said to have lasted for several days, during which Vyasa imparted advanced spiritual knowledge to Madhvacharya and confirmed the correctness of his philosophy.

Madhvacharya Jayanti is celebrated with great devotion and enthusiasm, particularly in South India where his influence is strongest. The festival typically falls on the Vijaya Dashami day in the month of Ashwin, typically between September and October according to the Gregorian calendar.

Madhvacharya Jayanti serves multiple purposes. It’s a day to remember and honour the life and teachings of Madhvacharya. For followers of the Dvaita philosophy, it’s a time for spiritual introspection and renewal of their commitment to Madhvacharya’s teachings. The festival provides an occasion to educate people, especially the younger generation, about Madhvacharya’s philosophy and contributions to Indian thought. It brings together the community of Madhvacharya’s followers, strengthening their bonds and shared spiritual heritage.

The celebration of Madhvacharya Jayanti involves various rituals and activities. Temples dedicated to Madhvacharya or those belonging to the Dvaita tradition conduct special pujas or worship ceremonies on this day. Devotees often engage in the recitation of Madhvacharya’s works or texts that he commented upon, such as the Bhagavad Gita. Scholars and spiritual leaders give discourses on Madhvacharya’s philosophy and its relevance in contemporary times. Many communities organise cultural programs featuring devotional music and dance performances. Following Madhvacharya’s teachings on social reform, many followers engage in charitable activities on this day. Some devotees observe a fast on this day as a form of spiritual discipline and many try to visit Udupi, the centre of Madhvacharya’s activities, or other places associated with his life.

Madhvacharya’s influence extends far beyond his immediate followers. His ideas have had a lasting impact on Indian philosophy and spirituality. Madhvacharya’s philosophy significantly influenced later Vaishnava thinkers. The founder of Gaudiya Vaishnavism, Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, and his followers thoroughly studied Madhvacharya’s works before developing their philosophy. The prominent Gaudiya Vaishnava theologian, Jiva Goswami, drew heavily from Madhvacharya’s writings in composing his works. 

Madhvacharya’s emphasis on devotion or bhakti as a means of spiritual realisation contributed to the broader Bhakti movement in India. His teachings helped make devotional practices more accessible to common people, regardless of their caste or social status. Madhvacharya established a strong tradition of disciplic succession. Notable scholars in this lineage include Jayatirtha, Vyasatirtha, and Raghavendra Tirtha, who further developed and propagated Dvaita philosophy.

Source

The eight mathas or monasteries established by Madhvacharya in Udupi continue to be important centres of learning and spiritual practice. The most famous among these is the Udupi Krishna Matha, known for its unique tradition of Krishna worship. 

Madhvacharya identified Vishnu as the Supreme Being, possessing infinite auspicious qualities. He taught that God is independent and self-existent; the world is dependent on God for its existence and functioning; God is the efficient and material cause of the universe; and divine grace is essential for salvation.

Regarding the individual soul or jiva, Madhvacharya taught that souls are eternal and innumerable, each soul is unique and maintains its individuality even after liberation, the soul is inherently dependent on God, and knowledge of one’s true nature as a servant of God is crucial for spiritual progress.

Unlike some Indian philosophical schools that view the world as an illusion, Madhvacharya asserted that the world is real, not illusory, the diversity we see in the world is real and not merely an appearance, and the world is subject to God’s control and exists for His pleasure.

Madhvacharya outlined a clear path to spiritual liberation. These are Knowledge or Jnana which is understanding the nature of God, soul, and the world; devotion or Bhakti which means cultivating loving devotion to Lord Vishnu; detachment or Vairagya by which one develops dispassion towards worldly pleasures, and divine grace because ultimately, liberation depends on God’s grace.

A unique aspect of Madhvacharya’s philosophy is the concept of gradation among souls. He proposed that souls are categorised based on their inherent qualities and potential for liberation and some souls are destined for eternal liberation, some for eternal bondage, and others which will oscillate between the two states. This concept of gradation and eternal damnation for some souls has been one of the more controversial aspects of Madhvacharya’s philosophy.

While Madhvacharya lived and taught in the 13th century, his ideas continue to be relevant in the modern world. His emphasis on the reality of difference resonates with modern ideas of pluralism and diversity. The concept of each soul being unique underscores the importance of individual worth and potential. Madhvacharya’s emphasis on righteous living and devotion provides a framework for ethical behavior in daily life. His approach to critically examining existing philosophies encourages intellectual inquiry and debate. The view of the world as real and valuable can foster a sense of responsibility towards the environment. 

Like any philosophical system, Madhvacharya’s Dvaita has faced challenges and criticisms. The idea that some souls are eternally condemned has been difficult for many to accept. Critics argue that Madhvacharya’s conception of God is too anthropomorphic. Some scholars have questioned Madhvacharya’s interpretations of Vedic texts, arguing that they are sometimes forced to fit his philosophical framework. Critics have pointed out perceived logical inconsistencies in some aspects of Dvaita philosophy. Despite these challenges, Madhvacharya’s philosophy continues to thrive and evolve, with modern scholars offering new interpretations and defences of his ideas.

While Madhvacharya Jayanti is primarily celebrated in India, particularly in the southern states, it has gained recognition globally due to the spread of Hinduism and the growing interest in Indian philosophy. The epicentre of Madhvacharya Jayanti celebrations is Udupi, Karnataka, where Madhvacharya established his primary matha. The Krishna Temple here becomes a focal point of festivities. Throughout Karnataka, especially in coastal regions, temples and mathas organise special pujas, discourses, and cultural programs. Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh, and Kerala also see significant celebrations, particularly in areas with a strong Madhva following. While celebrations are less prominent in North India, some Vaishnava communities do observe the day with devotional activities.

Madhvacharya Jayanti is more than just a birthday celebration; it’s a testament to the enduring impact of a philosopher who lived over 700 years ago. Madhvacharya’s life, teachings, and legacy continue to inspire millions, offering a unique perspective on the nature of reality, the divine, and the human condition. His emphasis on the reality of difference, the supremacy of Vishnu, and the path of devotion has left an indelible mark on Hindu philosophy and practice. The annual celebration of Madhvacharya Jayanti serves as a reminder of his contributions and an opportunity for spiritual renewal for his followers.

We’re reminded of the rich philosophical traditions of India and their continued relevance in our modern world. Whether one agrees with all aspects of his philosophy or not, there’s no denying the profound impact Madhvacharya has had on Indian thought and spirituality. 

2024 Week 41 Update

Posted on by
Reply

The 13th-century Persian poet, Islamic scholar, and Sufi mystic, Jalal ad-Din Muhammad Rumi is the author of our quote today. Born in 1207 in present-day Afghanistan, his works have transcended borders and time, making him one of the most beloved poets in history. Rumi’s poetry explores themes of love, spirituality, and the divine, blending deep philosophical reflections with lyrical beauty. His most famous work, the *Masnavi*, is considered one of the greatest works of mystical literature. His teachings continue to inspire people around the world, emphasising unity, love, and the pursuit of inner truth.

Rumi’s quote emphasises the power of thoughtful, gentle communication over aggression or loudness. The quote suggests that it is not the volume of our words that matters, but the substance and wisdom behind them. Just as rain nurtures growth gently, calm and meaningful words can lead to understanding and positive change, whereas forceful or angry speech, like thunder, can be disruptive and ineffective. Rumi highlights that raising the quality and depth of what we say, rather than becoming louder or more forceful, is the way to build connection and foster growth in relationships. It also speaks to the idea that subtle, quiet strength (like the rain) is far more powerful and nurturing than aggressive or destructive actions (like thunder).

After nine nights, the festival of Navaratri finally came to an end and now we have Diwali to look forward to. I need to start planning what to make for the festival, check my pantry stock and purchase what is needed. And after nine days of eating sundal, usually made of some sort of lentil, my stomach needs some rest before the onslaught of the Diwali sweets and savouries!

That’s all from my side this week, so take care and talk soon!

In My Hands Today…

Posted on by
Reply

The Map That Changed the World: William Smith and the Birth of Modern Geology – Simon Winchester

William Smith was not rich or well connected, but his passion for rocks and fossils, and his twenty-year obsession with single-handedly mapping the geology of Britain made him one of the most significant men of the nineteenth century.

However his vision cost him dear – his wife went mad, his work was stolen by jealous colleagues who eventually ruined him, and he was imprisoned for debt.

Simon Winchester tells the fascinating story of ‘Strata’ Smith, a man who crossed boundaries of class, wealth and science to produce a map that fundamentally changed the way we view the world.

Festivals of India: Sindoor Khela

Posted on by
Reply
Source

Sindoor Khela, also known as Sindur Khela or Vermilion Play, is a vibrant and joyous Bengali Hindu tradition that takes place on the final day of Durga Puja, known as Vijayadashami. This colourful ritual is primarily celebrated by married women and is a beautiful expression of feminine energy, marital bliss, and sisterhood. As the grand festivities of Durga Puja come to a close, Sindoor Khela serves as a fitting finale, filled with laughter, camaraderie, and the vibrant red hue of sindoor or vermilion powder.

The exact origins of Sindoor Khela are not precisely documented, but the tradition is believed to have evolved over centuries as part of the broader Durga Puja celebrations in Bengal. Durga Puja itself has a rich history dating back to the late 16th and early 17th centuries, gaining prominence during the Bengal Renaissance of the 18th and 19th centuries.

Sindoor Khela likely emerged as a way for women to come together and celebrate their marital status, fertility, and the divine feminine energy embodied by Goddess Durga. The use of sindoor in Hindu traditions has ancient roots, with references in texts dating back to the Vedic period, around 1500–500 BCE.

In Bengali culture, sindoor holds great significance for married women. It is applied along the parting of their hair, known as sindoor daan, as a visible symbol of their married status. The red color of sindoor is associated with the strength and power of Shakti, the primordial cosmic energy represented by the divine feminine.

The tradition of Sindoor Khela may have originated as a way for women to reaffirm their marital bonds and seek the blessings of Goddess Durga for a long and prosperous married life. Over time, it evolved into a more inclusive celebration, embracing the spirit of sisterhood and female empowerment.

Source

While there isn’t a specific mythological story directly tied to the origin of Sindoor Khela, several legends and beliefs associated with sindoor and Goddess Durga provide context for the ritual’s significance. According to Hindu mythology, Durga Puja celebrates the annual visit of Goddess Durga to her maternal home on Earth. On Vijayadashami, she prepares to return to her abode in Mount Kailash, where her husband Lord Shiva resides. Sindoor Khela is seen as a way for mortal women to bid farewell to the Goddess and seek her blessings before she departs.

In one version of the Sati legend, when Lord Shiva carried the lifeless body of his wife Sati after she immolated herself, parts of her body fell at different locations, creating Shakti Peethas. It is said that at the Kalighat temple in Kolkata, Sati’s right toe fell, and the sindoor from her forehead touched the ground. This story connects the use of sindoor to the divine feminine energy of Shakti. Some folklore suggests that Lord Krishna applied sindoor on Radha’s forehead as a symbol of their eternal love. This tale emphasises the romantic and devotional aspects associated with sindoor. In Hindu tradition, sindoor is considered a symbol of saubhagya or marital bliss and good fortune. It is believed that applying sindoor invokes the blessings of the divine for a long and happy married life.

Sindoor Khela typically takes place on the afternoon of Vijayadashami, after the formal rituals of Durga Puja have concluded. The celebration unfolds in several stages – married women gather at the Durga Puja pandal, a temporary structure housing the Durga idol dressed in traditional Bengali attire, usually white sarees with red borders. The women first offer prayers to Goddess Durga, seeking her blessings and expressing gratitude for the festivities. As part of the ritual, women apply sindoor to the feet and forehead of the Durga idol, symbolically preparing her for her journey back to Mount Kailash. The main event begins as women start applying sindoor to each other’s foreheads and along the parting of their hair. This is done with great enthusiasm, often resulting in faces, necks, and parts of the saree being covered in the red powder. Women exchange sweets and bless each other, wishing for happiness, prosperity, and longevity in their married lives. The ritual often culminates in dancing and singing, with women forming circles and enjoying the festive atmosphere. While traditionally limited to married women, in many communities, Sindoor Khela has become more inclusive, allowing widows, divorced women, and even unmarried women to participate in the spirit of sisterhood and celebration.

Source

Sindoor Khela holds deep significance in Bengali culture and Hindu traditions. The ritual celebrates the power and beauty of womanhood, emphasising the strength and grace embodied by Goddess Durga. For married women, it’s a way to reaffirm their marital status and seek blessings for a happy married life. The communal nature of the celebration fosters a sense of sisterhood and unity among women. The red colour of sindoor is associated with fertility and prosperity, symbolizing the life-giving power of women. During Sindoor Khela, social barriers often dissolve as women from different backgrounds come together in celebration. The ritual is an important marker of Bengali cultural identity, preserving traditions and passing them on to future generations. For many women, Sindoor Khela provides a rare opportunity for uninhibited joy and expression, offering emotional release and bonding.

While Sindoor Khela is primarily associated with Bengali Hindu culture, similar traditions can be found in other parts of India, albeit with regional variations. In Odisha, a similar ritual called “Aparajita” is performed during Kumar Purnima, where women play with powdered rice and flowers. During Gudi Padwa celebrations, Maharashtrian women participate in “Haldi Kumkum,” exchanging turmeric and vermilion as symbols of auspiciousness. In some North Indian communities, women exchange sindoor during Karva Chauth festivities.

As society evolves, so does the celebration of Sindoor Khela. Many communities now welcome women of all marital statuses to participate, promoting a more inclusive celebration of womanhood. With growing environmental awareness, some groups are opting for eco-friendly, organic sindoor or even using flower petals as a colorful alternative. Bengali communities worldwide now celebrate Sindoor Khela, adapting the tradition to local contexts while preserving its essence. The vibrant visuals of Sindoor Khela have made it popular on social media platforms, increasing awareness and appreciation of the tradition globally. Contemporary artists and photographers often capture the essence of Sindoor Khela, creating powerful imagery that celebrates feminine energy and cultural heritage.

Source

While Sindoor Khela is largely celebrated as a joyous tradition, it has faced some criticism and controversy in recent years. The traditional focus on married women has been criticized for excluding other women, though many communities are now becoming more inclusive. Some argue that the emphasis on marital status perpetuates patriarchal norms and reduces women’s identity to their marital roles. The use of synthetic sindoor, which may contain harmful chemicals, has raised health and environmental concerns, prompting a shift towards natural alternatives. Like many traditional festivals, Sindoor Khela has seen increased commercialisation, which some feel dilutes its spiritual and cultural significance. As the tradition gains global attention, there are concerns about potential cultural appropriation and misrepresentation. Despite these critiques, many participants and cultural experts argue that the essence of Sindoor Khela lies in its celebration of feminine energy, community bonding, and cultural heritage, which transcends its association with marital status.

Sindoor Khela stands as a vibrant testament to the enduring power of cultural traditions and their ability to adapt to changing times. This colorful celebration encapsulates the joy, strength, and unity of women, while also serving as a bridge between ancient customs and modern sensibilities. Rooted in the rich tapestry of Bengali Hindu culture, Sindoor Khela has grown from a ritual celebrating marital status to a more inclusive festival of womanhood and sisterhood. Its evolution reflects broader societal changes, demonstrating how traditions can remain relevant by embracing new interpretations while preserving their core essence. 

The festival’s growing popularity and adaptations across different communities highlight its universal appeal. The images of women laughing, dancing, and covered in vibrant red sindoor have become powerful symbols of joy, freedom, and female bonding, transcending cultural and geographical boundaries. As we look to the future, Sindoor Khela has the potential to play an important role in cultural preservation, women’s empowerment, and community building. Ultimately, Sindoor Khela reminds us of the importance of celebrating life, honoring traditions, and coming together in joyous harmony. As it continues to evolve, this beautiful tradition will undoubtedly remain a cherished part of cultural heritage, spreading its message of love, unity, and feminine power for generations to come.